Peterson Field Guide to Birds of Eastern and Central North America, 6th Edition (Peterson Field Guides)
Peterson Field Guide to Birds of Eastern and Central North America, 6th Edition (Peterson Field Guides)
- Guide to birds of eastern and central north america
- This book guides a unique identification system, which has been called the greatest invention since binoculars
- This guide is illustrated with drawings and photographs in color and black and white and all provide up to date range information and the most useful descriptions
- A 128 pages colorful book
- Measures 8.50-inch width by 11-inch length
Guide to birds of eastern and central north america guides a unique identification system, which has been called the greatest invention since binoculars. This guide is illustrated with drawings and photographs in color and black and white and all provide up to date range information and the most useful descriptions, pinpoints key field marks for quick recognition and easy comparison of species. Measures 4-1/2-inch length by 7-1/4-inch width.Product Description
With all-new range maps, updat
List Price: $ 24.29
Price: $ 10.00
Related Bird Watching Products
Still a great guide, but losing ground,
As soon as They were available I signed up for the pre-order of both the eastern and western editions. I have had them now for around 5 months, and they have never left the house. I can only really comment on the eastern edition, because I never had a previous western ed., but I assume this applies to both.
The book’s content is at least 95% the same as the previous edition. I have spotted an added picture or two, but not many. Colors have been changed slightly, but I am not sure that they are better, and it may just be the printing process. The text is updated to agree with current information, bird names, etc., but I haven’t noticed much else. In that the pictures and information in the guides has always been excellent, all well and good.
The complaint I have is that the book is just no longer a FIELD GUIDE to me, as past editions were. It is thicker, somewhat heavier, and for a very poor reason, in my estimation. The difference is primarily in the back section of range maps, which has almost doubled in size. It takes up roughly 1/4 of the total size of the book. Now, we all refer to a range map from time to time, but I would bet its something like 1 in 300 times we use the book. Beyond that, the regular pages have smaller maps for the birds which suffice very well at least 95% of the time. To waste all that space and weight is ridiculous. If it is necessary to include all those large maps, I suggest they should be published separately and packaged with the guides, letting the user decide whether or not to carry them. I’m betting not 1/10 of 1% would. The old guide slid nicely into a pocket of my field pants. I won’t be doing that with the new one, I’d be afraid it would rip the pocket out, if I could get it in at all. The newest National Geo. guides are top notch, and they are smaller, thinner, and lighter than Peterson, as are others. The “big Sibley” has become the bible for most birders, although mine will never leave the house or car because of size, so that leaves out the new Peterson from any primarly use other than possibly the “bird feeder birder”. My feeling is, the people at Peterson “just don’t get it” as far as their niche in the guide book business goes. I feel guilty for being a detractor of this “new standard”, but I would feel more guilty if I did not.
0
Was this review helpful to you?
|Peterson is still the best for bird ID!,
0
Was this review helpful to you?
|Better Still!,
If I had any criticism to level at this new edition, it’s that the the text is often spare. Terminology and useful explanations of plumage features in the 5th edition that would confuse or overwhelm only the newest birdwatcher has often been omitted entirely. Understandably, this guide has long been a favorite of beginners, but I resent “dumbing down” of one of the few references one is likely to carry into the field. (If nothing else, it means a beginner is likely to outgrow this guide sooner than he or she ought to.) Finally, was the publisher unable to find a better picture of Mr. Peterson than the one they used for the back cover? Yikes!
0
Was this review helpful to you?
|